This post includes additional info and graphics along with the published article from the July 2013 issue of The Chesapeake Angler.
Sheepshead can give one heck of an adrenaline rush, especially in a kayak. The stark contrasting bars that mark their body earned them nickname, convict. And when hooked, they definitely run like they just broke out of jail. A trophy sized sheepshead will put your tackle to the test and challenge your ability to negotiate the structures they dwell. Kayakers who know what to look for can take advantage of the world class sheepshead fishery that is the Chesapeake Bay.
Starting in mid June through late October, Sheepshead can be found on most structures in the Chesapeake Bay. The CBBT bridge structures along with the rock islands tend to hold the biggest convicts. One of the advantages of fishing in a kayak is that we can rub right up against the pilings. I like to feel for rubble at the bottom and target those pilings most. Sheepshead are also known to stay suspended and even just under the surface near the pilings. They have also been known to hang underneath schools of spadefish as well.
Baits of choice are fiddler crabs or mole crabs aka sand fleas. Fiddlers can either be caught in the marsh or bought at most tackle/bait shops in the area. My preference is to take the big claw off and send the hook through the subsequent hole and out through the top. I'll save the big claws just in case I run out of fiddlers. I've caught big sheepshead on just the claw. Mole crabs can be caught in the surf using various methods, including hand digging, as well as half a minnow trap sifted through the sand where the water meets the sand, but a mole crab rake is best. I hook the mole crabs through the apron (small flap on the underside) and send the barb through the top. Convicts will also eat various other crustaceans, including clams, mussels, other crabs, etc.
I normally start by working the bottom, but if I don't get a bite after a few minutes, I'll reel up 4-5 cranks and suspend the bait. The bite is hard to explain. They can be quite the bait stealer, but once you figure out the bite, you’ll figure out the timing of when to set the hook. In the mean time, for beginners, I’d suggest to go ahead and swing if you think there was a bite. I’d rather swing and miss than bring up an empty hook over and over again. Sometimes you’ll just feel a sudden weight on the other end without even feeling a bite. For that situation, definitely go ahead and swing. If you feel a heavy weight, reel as much line in as you can before it realizes what's happening.
The ensuing runs will astonish even seasoned anglers. If you’re fishing around a piling and it starts taking you around the structure; as soon as you feel your line rubbing the piling put your reel in free spool and paddle through then engage again. Otherwise your chances at pulling that big sheepie back through are slim to none.
A note about the sheepshead I’d like to share is that once they reach the 20-22” range they take a very long time to grow to trophy size. Although they are excellent table fare, I urge you to consider releasing trophy size sheepsheads (24” and above) since we would all like to see the specie thrive for a long time.
